California OTA Rejects Unitary-Business Sourcing of Gain - Forvis Mazars US

California’s Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) Ruling on Unitary Business

The OTA found that a holding company, Watts Holdings, Inc. (WHI) and its operating LLC, Sunstate Equipment Co., LLC (Sunstate), were not engaged in a unitary business in December 2012. This means the gain from the sale of WHI's interest in Sunstate was considered nonbusiness income allocable outside California, rather than business income apportionable to the state.

The Watts Case Details

On February 28, 2025, the OTA issued an opinion reversing the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) and ruling against WHI and Sunstate. The FTB had initially proposed assessments, arguing that WHI and Sunstate were unitary, but the OTA disagreed. After a petition for rehearing, the OTA stood by its decision, stating that the FTB did not present any valid grounds for reconsideration.

Sunstate operated an equipment rental business nationwide, including in California, and was treated as a partnership for federal tax purposes. WHI was an Arizona holding company that became an S corporation in 2012, owning an interest in Sunstate. WHI also owned Sunstate Aviation and Leasing, LLC (Aviation), which leased aircraft to Sunstate and other entities.

In 2012, WHI received $149,900 from Sunstate, through Aviation, related to aircraft rental. Sumitomo acquired its interest in Sunstate in phases, starting in 2009. In December 2012, WHI sold additional Sunstate units to Sumitomo's affiliate, representing a 44.935% membership interest. WHI's 2012 California return reported significant gains from this sale.

Unitary Business Analysis

The central question was whether WHI and Sunstate were engaged in a unitary business in 2012, which would determine the sourcing of WHI's gain. California differentiates between business income, apportioned among states, and nonbusiness income, allocated to a specific state. For nonresident owners, income from intangibles is sourced outside California unless the intangible has established a business situs in the state.

M.L. Watts and C. Watts, California nonresident shareholders of WHI, argued that WHI and Sunstate were not unitary, and thus, the gain from the sale should be allocated outside California.

Leave a Reply