Beyond DExit: Recent Developments in State Corporate Law, Business Courts, and Jurisdictional Competition
This year, we delve into the post-legislative landscape of corporate governance, specifically examining the real-world impact of recent reforms in state corporate law, business courts, and jurisdictional competition.
Corporate Governance & Executive Compensation Survey: Part 4
Last year's survey provided a comprehensive overview of legislative changes reshaping the jurisdictional landscape for U.S. corporations, from Delaware's amendments to the DGCL to Texas's establishment of its Business Court and Nevada's adoption of AB 239.
Litigating Reforms: Signal vs. Noise
This year, the focus shifts from legislation to litigation. We explore two key questions:
- Are the reforms holding up? We analyze significant rulings from Delaware and Texas that provide initial judicial validation (or limitations) on 2025's legislative reforms.
- How much of "DExit" is real versus perception? Using data from the Delaware Division of Corporations, proxy season results, and updates through mid-2026, we dissect companies' incorporation and reincorporation choices.
Delaware: Courts and Legislature in Action
Delaware has been proactive, with both its courts and legislature addressing outstanding issues to maintain predictability, a key factor in its status as the leading corporate governance jurisdiction.
In re Tesla: Honoring Corporate Governance Choices
The Delaware Court of Chancery demonstrated its commitment to upholding companies' governance decisions, even when they involve litigation outside Delaware. In In re Tesla, Vice Chancellor Bonnie W. David dismissed three derivative suits, enforcing Tesla's Texas exclusive-forum bylaw retroactively, despite the suits predating the bylaw's adoption. This ruling signifies Delaware's willingness to enforce forum-selection bylaws, providing reassurance to companies reincorporating to Texas or Nevada.
Texas: Building a Judicial Track Record
Texas's story is one of momentum, transitioning from legislative ambition to a growing body of judicial opinions. The Texas Business Court has issued key corporate governance decisions, a federal court upheld the validity of SB 29's derivative suit ownership requirement, and several major companies have reincorporated in the state.
Gusinsky v. Reynolds: SB 29's First Major Test
Gusinsky v. Reynolds is a pivotal judicial development in Texas corporate law. A federal district court dismissed a derivative action, holding that SB 29's ownership threshold barred the claim. The court rejected two key arguments, setting a precedent for future derivative suits under the new legislation.
In Conclusion:
The landscape of corporate governance is evolving rapidly, with reforms navigating the fine line between signal and noise. This survey aims to provide clarity in this dynamic environment, offering insights into the real impact of recent developments.