Why It Matters
The Small Business Administration (SBA) recovered less than 1% of the $616.2 million in overpayments identified across its programs in fiscal year 2025, compared with 62% government-wide, according to a U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report on SBA improper payments. For the 7(a) loan guaranty and standard Economic Injury Disaster Loan (EIDL) programs, the agency does not conduct recovery audits, a review of accounting and financial records to identify and recover overpayments. This lack of audits has been in place for 10 years for 7(a) and 15 years for standard EIDL programs.
The Big Picture
The Payment Integrity Information Act of 2019 requires federal agencies to estimate improper payments for high-risk programs and conduct recovery audits if cost-effective. In 2025, SBA estimated about $2 billion in improper payments for the programs GAO reviewed. SBA's Office of Inspector General reported the agency was not compliant with the act due to issues with the reliability of its estimates.
GAO's Review
GAO was asked to review SBA's estimates and recovery audits. They analyzed the agency's methods for fiscal years 2020 through 2024 for various programs and interviewed six federal agencies with high recovery rates.
GAO found that while SBA's estimates met basic statistical requirements, the agency did not document the basis for key decisions, including its assumption about the likelihood of improper payments across loan sizes. It also did not consider whether the Paycheck Protection Program and COVID-19 EIDL estimates adequately reflected known fraud risks. As a result, GAO stated that SBA "cannot be sure that its estimates accurately reflect improper payment risks."
SBA's Response
SBA informed GAO that it recovers overpayments through other methods, such as collecting a portion with each regular loan payment. GAO noted that factors affecting the cost-effectiveness of recovery audits have changed over the past decade.
The Bottom Line
SBA received four recommendations, all addressed to its administrator. While SBA disagreed with the first two, it agreed or partially agreed with the other two. GAO maintains that all four recommendations are valid.
The implications extend beyond SBA's finances. The agency's estimates guide its focus on correcting improper payment risks, and the Payment Integrity Information Act requires agencies to estimate and conduct audits when cost-effective.