It should be a time of celebration
It should be a time of celebration. At long last, the oil and gas companies that battled the state, trying to avoid responsibility for their role in our coastal land loss crisis, are paying up. Lawsuits that have dragged on for more than a decade are finally seeing some resolution, and the Louisiana communities that for too long have borne the cost could finally see some restitution.
But when and how much? That's why we're not yet cheering. Few people know the answer to those questions because the settlements negotiated with Big Oil companies are being kept under wraps. So far, Shell, Exxon, and BP are among the big names who have settled.
John Carmouche, the lawyer handling the suits for the state and the parishes affected, said the total settlement could reach as high as $7 billion. But how much of that goes to coastal restoration? How much is designated for the coastal communities where the damage occurred? How much is in real dollars rather than carbon credits or other environmental mitigation?
We'd love to know, but the companies sought court orders to keep the terms of these settlements confidential, and the state did not oppose them. Carmouche says that publicizing how much other companies paid out could weaken the state's position in future negotiations, and that all will be made public once all the deals are done. But who knows when that will be?
The tranche of lawsuits is part of litigation that involves 42 companies in total. The latest settlement, with oil giant BP, was announced in October. The Chevron case is still being litigated after a Supreme Court ruling earlier this year overturned a $745 million verdict by a jury in Plaquemines Parish.
Meanwhile, details of the agreements are trickling out as the state does other business. The deal with SpaceX, for example, included land in Vermilion Parish that Exxon gave to the state as part of its settlement. SpaceX paid $100 million for roughly 125,000 acres, money that ostensibly will be used to restore the coast. But again, who knows? The state has indicated that some of the settlement money will be used to plug abandoned oil wells — something we have urged the state to take seriously. But that is not coastal restoration.
Gov. Jeff Landry and his administration have essentially said "trust us."
"As governor I have worked to responsibly and ethically clean up the litigation environment that has impacted one of our largest employers — the oil and gas industry," he said in a statement.
That may all be true. Still, we believe that the public's business needs to be conducted in public. Our public officials should not be negotiating deals behind our backs.
Politicians frequently whine that they never get credit for the good they do. We would love to be able to applaud these settlements as beneficial to the people of Louisiana. Too bad they are making it so hard for us to do so.