Fort Smith Board Delays Adoption of Animal Services Contract
Like an excited puppy in a new place, opinions and sometimes pointed comments were all over the place during Tuesday’s (Nov. 10) discussion by the Fort Smith Board of Directors about a proposed 10-year contract with Fort Smith Animal Haven (FSAH) that could cost more than $1 million a year.
The board would eventually decide – in a close 4-3 vote – to move consideration of the contract to the board’s Dec. 1 regular meeting.
According to a memo from Fort Smith City Administrator Jeff Dingman, the FSAH, which is now contracted by the city to handle certain animal control services, is asking the city to approve a contract “that proposes renewal of services, an increase in both fixed fees and variable costs, and an initial 10-year term with a provision for an additional five years upon mutual agreement.”
The new contract would see the city’s fee to FSAH rise from around $63,400 a month to around $76,000 a month.
Much of the opposition from some board members and citizens who attended the board meeting centered around the contract having a 10-year term, lack of a competitive bidding process, no certain annual cost, and “no clear metrics” for contract performance. Director Neal Martin, who cited the lack of metrics, was one of the directors pushing to delay the vote to “tighten up” the contract.
Fort Smith attorney Joey McCutchen, who has successfully sued the city over Freedom of Information Act and other statutory violations, told the board to prepare for a lawsuit if they approved such a large contract amount without going through a public bidding process.
“You’ve been sued once, and you’ll probably be sued again,” McCutchen said during the public comment period. “I don’t see a need demonstrated as to why competitive bidding was not feasible.”
Director André Good argued for approval of the contract, saying FSAH is providing services to meet a “large gap” of animal service needs in the city. He said the costs for the city to directly address that gap would be much more costly than the FSAH contract. Director Jarred Rego said the contract is a “reasonable request” from an agency that has a lot of community support.
It was also learned during the board discussion that the most recent contract proposal between the city and FSAH was not included in the board packet or placed on the website for public review. Colby Roe, an attorney with Fort Smith-based Daily & Woods, the law firm that represents the city, said he was not sure why the most recent contract was not part of the public discussion.
The wrong contract was discovered when questions were asked when the new contract would go into effect. The city’s existing contract with FSAH expires in April. Director Christina Catsavis and other directors wanted to know if the new contract would be effective when the existing contract expires, or if there would be overlap. It was then that Coe acknowledged that the most recent contract was not part of the board’s materials.
With numerous concerns raised about the proposed contract, Martin moved to have those concerns addressed and an amended contract returned to the board at the Jan. 5 regular meeting. Director Christina Catsavis, who often suggested such a long-term and detailed contract be delayed to allow more review, seconded Martin’s motion. That motion failed in a 4-3 vote.
However, Director Lee Kemp, who supported passage of the FSAH contract, made a motion – as a courtesy to board members with concerns – to move consideration of the contract to the board’s Dec. 1 regular meeting. That motion was approved 4-3.